From Basic to Beautiful, These Top-Rated Bakeware Sets Cover All of Your Essential Baking Needs

From Basic to Beautiful, These Top-Rated Bakeware Sets Cover All of Your Essential Baking Needs

Our editors independently select the products we recommend. We may earn a commission on items bought through our links.

If you love creating homemade brownies, cakes, cookies, muffins, loaves of bread and other tasty treats, then your bakeware probably earns its keep. Whether you’re well practiced at baking or new to the hobby (as many who discovered baking in the pandemic are), one of the best bakeware sets will allow you to whip up everything your heart desires, from sugar cookies to jelly rolls.

These comprehensive kits are also surprisingly versatile home additions. It doesn’t matter if you’re looking to replace an old set which has come to the end of its baking journey, want to give the latest TikTok baking trends a go or need a gift for a foodie who loves to bake, one of the best bakeware sets will likely do the job. But what is the best bakeware set to buy? To help you answer this question, we’ve covered the key factors to consider, in addition to compiling a list of the best bakeware sets you’ll find anywhere on the internet.

What Is the Best Bakeware Set?

Even if your budget is the biggest deciding factor in your decision, for consistent, successful results, the best baking set always needs to be easy to use, capable of enduring extreme temperatures and perhaps most importantly, easy to clean — especially after having all kinds of sugary treats burned on. Another good idea is to find a set made up of pieces that you think you will actually use, as this won’t waste storage space in your kitchen. However, if you’re unsure what you’ll be using and what you won’t, or if it’s a gift for someone else, a bigger set may be the smarter way to go.

Having covered the functional side of things, let’s now talk about form. Many bakers, with an emphasis on millennials, appreciate products that look as good as they function. But you don’t need to be drowning in college debt to appreciate great design. If this speaks to you, you’ll be happy to know that DTC brands like Caraway and Our Place have standout bakeware sets inspired by the colorful heritage pieces your grandmother might have used in the 50s or 60s. 

In the shopping guide below, we’ve included the best bakeware sets from all the top brands as well as more basic options for folks on a budget or stocking their kitchen for the first time.

Our Place Ovenware Set
The new ovenware set from Our Place.

The Most Essential Pieces To Look for in Bakeware Sets

When it comes to putting the best bakewear set together for your home, there are several pieces that should be included in every collection and some that are a matter of personal preference. Here’s a handy list of the baking items which may be included in the best ovenware sets for bakers:

  • Unrimmed baking/cookie sheets
  • Rimmed baking sheets
  • 9×13-inch cake pan
  • 9-inch round cake pan
  • 9×9-inch square cake pan
  • Loaf
  • 9-inch pie pan
  • Muffin tin
  • Tart pan
  • Muffin top pan
  • Sheet cake/jelly roll pan

If you’re ready to invest in one of the best bakeware sets of 2023, scroll down to discover SPY’s top 15 picks you can order online. From budget-friendly kits to arrays you would find in a professional kitchen, we’ve got options for every level of baker.

best bakeware sets caraway


1. Caraway Bakeware Set

We were really excited when Caraway announced its first bakeware set, and even though it’s more of an investment than some of the other options on the list, we think it’s more than worth it. The popular 11-piece set ticks all the right boxes, including being non-toxic, non-stick and particularly easy to clean. The aluminized steel construction and ceramic surfaces are oven safe up to 550°F and help to evenly heat food from edge to edge for more consistent results than competing bakeware sets. Furthermore, our top pick is available in seven colors, is backed by more than 2,900 five-star ratings from Caraway customers and comes with a set of bakeware organizers to give you a place to store your bakeware set.

Why It’s the Best: This is a true heritage collection that should last a lifetime, and the durable steel pieces are covered in an attractive and non-toxic ceramic coating. This bakeware set is also oven safe up to 550 degrees, up to 100 degrees higher than typical bakeware sets.

  • Number of items: 11 pieces
  • Material: Aluminum steel, non-toxic ceramic coating
  • Best Features: Storage rack included, 7 color options, oven safe up to 550 degrees
best bakeware sets all clad pro release


2. All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set

With several pans and sheets and a cooling rack, this 10-piece All-Clad Pro-Release Nonstick Bakeware Set has every angle covered. It makes a great gift idea for the baker in your life and also comes with five-star ratings from more than 85% of Amazon users who own it. The pieces in the set are oven safe to 450°F and made from a commercial-grade aluminized steel that has been coated in a food-safe, PFOA-free, ceramic reinforced nonstick material. This results in pans and sheets that are resistant to stains, scratches, sticking and warping.

  • Number of items: 10 pieces
  • Material: Commercial grade aluminized steel
  • Best Features: Non-stick surface, oversized integrated handles
best bakeware sets rachel ray cucina


3. Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set

With a five-star rating from more than 8,000 five-star ratings from Amazon users who own it, the Rachael Ray Cucina Nonstick Bakeware Set was definitely vying for the top spot. This standout collection of pans and sheets has everything the average baker could want. Whether you choose the four-, five- or 10-piece option, all items are made from heavy gauge steel and feature silicone grips to provide confidence during handling, even when things are hot. Additionally, the rectangular cake pan (only included in the 10-piece set) comes with a lid for greater storage and transport options. While it’s not quite as well designed as more chic options, it’s a sensible and affordable choice that gives you all the most important items you need.

  • Number of items: 10 pieces
  • Material: Carbon
  • Best Features: Heavy gauge steel construction, silicone grips
best bakeware sets amazon basics


4. Amazon Basics Nonstick Oven Bakeware Baking Set

At under $45 and with more than 11,000 five-star ratings from Amazon users, the Amazon Basics NonstickOven Bakeware Baking Set is another reliable and budget-friendly answer to the average household’s bakeware needs. This six-piece set includes a loaf pan, two cake pans, a muffin pan, a roast pan and a baking sheet. Each piece in the set is constructed from tough and durable carbon steel with a non-stick coating, ensuring it’s easy to clean and remove food from.

  • Number of items: 6 pieces
  • Material: Carbon steel
  • Best Features: Non-stick coating, oven safe up to 500 degrees
best bakeware sets great jones fully baked


5. Great Jones Fully Baked

If you’re looking for a bakeware set which really stands out from the crowd, this Great Jones Fully Baked Set definitely fits the bill. The set is available in either blueberry blue or broccoli green and comes with the Hot Dish and the Sweetie Pie, which are both covered by an eye-catching design. The set is ideal for creating baked delights such as banana bread or biscuit cobbler. Additionally, the materials are all oven and dishwasher safe, non-stick and non-toxic, ensuring cleaning and removing baked food is always quick and easy.

  • Number of items: 7 (Great Jones Fully Baked) or 4 pieces (Great Jones Easy Bake)
  • Material: Mixed materials
  • Best Features: Vibrant colors
best bakeware sets our place


6. Our Place Ovenware Set

The new Our Place ovenware set isn’t just for baking, and so it’s a great choice for home chefs that love to whip up both sweet and savory dishes alike. As you would expect from Our Place, the DTC brand whose kitchen tools have a cult following, the entire Ovenware set is absolutely beautiful. You can choose from five different attractive colors, and if you already own the company’s famous Always pan, you can match your colors. This 5-piece set is surprisingly affordable, and it’s easily one of the best bakeware sets under $200. You’ll be missing out on muffin trays and some other items you’ll find in larger 10-piece sets.

  • Number of items: 5 pieces
  • Material: Stoneware coated in non-stick ceramic
  • Best Features: Beautiful design, natural and non-toxic materials
best bakeware sets williams sonoma goldtouch


7. Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Bakers Dream Set

If you like the idea of having every baking angle covered, consider this 25-piece Williams Sonoma Goldtouch Pro Bakers Dream Set. From a pizza pan and pie dishes to cooling racks and several cake pans of different sizes, this comprehensive collection includes everything you need to produce baked goods of every shape and size. In addition, each piece of gold-colored bakeware is dishwasher safe and won’t corrode, scratch, rust or stain, even after years of baking.

  • Number of items: 25 pieces
  • Material: Aluminum steel
  • Best Features: Non-stick coating
best bakeware sets faberware


8. Farberware Nonstick Bakeware Set

If you’re looking to cover all of your essential baking needs, the Farberware 10-Piece Nonstick Bakeware Set could be what you’re searching for. The 10-piece set includes baking sheets, a muffin pan, cake pans, a loaf pan and a cooling rack. The pieces are made from warp-resistant, solid steel that evenly distributes heat during baking to produce more consistent results. Plus, the non-stick coating is some of the best rated on the market and ideal for the more forgetful bakers who have a tendency to overcook their baked goods.

  • Number of items: 10 pieces
  • Material: Solid steel
  • Best Features: Dishwasher safe
best bakeware sets anolon


9. Anolon Advanced Nonstick Bakeware Set

The five pieces included in this Anolon Advanced Nonstick Bakeware Set feature a non-stick finish on both the inside and outside, meaning removing baked food and cleaning the pans after use is simple. They are also constructed from heavy-duty carbon steel for greater durability. You’ll also find rolled rims in the designs to help prevent warping and further increase durability. In addition, this set comes in either gray or bronze and is available in a three-piece option.

  • Number of items: 5 pieces
  • Material: Carbon steel
  • Best Features: Non-stick coating
best bakeware sets sur la table platinum


10. Sur La Table Platinum Pro Bakeware Set

In addition to providing a variety of non-stick, even-cooking surfaces for you use to create a range of baked goods, this Sur La Table Platinum Pro Bakeware Set sports a unique design which is worthy of being on show. Unlike the usual flat look the majority of bakeware items sport, these cake pans, muffin tin, half sheet and cooking pan rack feature a unique, corrugated look which also maximizes strength and resistance to heavy impacts. 

  • Number of items: 6 pieces
  • Material: Aluminized steel
  • Best Features: Unique corrugated construction with a fluted design
best bakeware sets lodge bakers delight


11. Lodge Baker’s Delight Set

Thanks to its cast iron construction, this Lodge Baker’s Delight Set is the most durable bakeware set on our list. The set is made up of a casserole dish, a baking pan, a pie pan, a baker’s skillet and a pair of silicone grips. The silicone grips are oven safe up to 425°F, dishwasher safe and easily clip onto the different Lodge bakeware when required. All the cast iron in this four-piece set is made in the USA and has been seasoned with 100% natural vegetable oil to produce greater flavor in your food.

  • Number of items: 4 pieces
  • Material: Cast iron
  • Best Features: Pre-seasoned, made in the USA
best bakeware sets circulon


12. Circulon Bakeware Nonstick Set

The Circulon Bakeware Nonstick Set is another top-rated bakeware collection that covers all your essential baking needs and then some. The 10-piece set is available in either brown or gray and comes with sheets, pans, a lid and a cooling rack. All pieces are dishwasher safe and free of PFOA. Furthermore, you’ll find a unique non-stick covering of raised circles for easier food release and there’s a Hassle-Free Lifetime Guarantee when you invest in this popular set.

  • Number of items: 6 pieces
  • Material: Cast iron
  • Best Features: Place on countertops straight out of the oven, dishwasher safe
best bakeware sets the bakeware


13. Made In French Porcelain Bakeware Set

The Made In The Bakeware Set is made from high-fired clay that gives the oval, rectangle and square-shaped dishes a glossy, stylish appearance. The three-piece set comes in a range of stylish designs, including red and white, blue and white and several one-color options. Seriously, these are gorgeous pieces of bakeware that you’ll be proud to keep in your home. On top of that, the French porcelain construction means cleaning and removing food is rarely a problem when baking with these pans. Furthermore, each dish features easy-grab handles to ensure you’re always in control when moving them to or from the oven.

  • Number of items: 3 pieces
  • Material: High-fired clay
  • Best Features: Beautiful designs, oven safe up to 480 degrees
best bakeware sets calphalon


14. Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set

If you’re particularly precious about your countertops and want to avoid accidentally setting a burning-hot pan on top of one, try this Calphalon Nonstick Bakeware Set. Each piece in the six-item set features silicone feet to allow them to be moved directly from the oven to a countertop without worry. Even the best bakeware sets are usually hand wash only, but all of the pieces in this set are dishwasher safe and sport interlocking, non-stick layers for easy cleaning and food release.

  • Number of items: 6 pieces
  • Material: Cast iron
  • Best Features: Place on countertops straight out of the oven, dishwasher safe
best bakeware sets sur la table classic


15. Sur La Table Silver Classic Bakeware Set

The Sur La Table Silver Classic 7-Piece Bakeware Set is another eye-catching offering. As well as its visually unique look, the bakeware items’ textured surface helps air to flow underneath, resulting in more even baking. The eco-friendly, non-stick silicone coating, which has been specially formulated for the job, is also highly effective and free from both PTFEs and PFOAs. Furthermore, the thickness of each pan is the result of years of performance data interpretation, adding to the sets reliability when it comes to evenly cooked baked goods.

  • Number of items: 7 pieces
  • Material: Aluminized steel
  • Best Features: Even cooking and unbeatable non-stickiness

The Best Nonstick Cookware Sets for Quick and Easy Stovetop Cooking
Back to blog

Leave a comment

Please note, comments need to be approved before they are published.